Commission-only vs salaried sales rep vs agency
Written by the founder of WedgeUp, which supports the commission-only route. I have said where each of the other two is the better choice. Cost figures come from the sources linked, and the worked example is illustrative.
A commission-only rep costs you nothing until they sell, but you get less control and less commitment. A salaried rep gives you control and costs you roughly a fifth more than their salary before they close anything. An agency sits in between, with its own fees and you managing a third party. The right choice depends on whether you have already proved the product sells.
The comparison
| Commission-only rep | Salaried rep | Sales agency | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cost before first sale | Nothing | Salary, plus employer costs, plus recruiter fee | Depends on the agency; some charge retainers, some only on results |
| Cost per sale | Commission | Salary, spread over sales | Fee or commission |
| Control over how they sell | Low. Self-employed people set their own hours and methods | High | Medium |
| Commitment to you | Low; they work for several people | High | Medium |
| Speed to start | Days to weeks | Weeks to months | Weeks |
| Risk if it does not work | Low | High | Medium |
| Best when | You are testing and the product is proved | You have repeatable sales and want a team | You want results and are happy to hand over the process |
What a salaried rep costs in the UK
On a £30,000 salary, the arithmetic looks roughly like this. This is illustrative, using the sources below; rates and thresholds change, so check current ones.
- Employer National Insurance: 15% on earnings above £5,000 a year from April 2025, so about £3,750 on £30,000 (NerdWallet UK).
- Minimum employer pension: 3% of qualifying pay under auto-enrolment, so a few hundred pounds.
- Employer costs overall: commonly 15% to 20% on top of gross pay, about £4,500 to £6,000 here.
- Recruiter fee, if you use one: typically 20% to 30% of salary, so £6,000 to £9,000 (British Business Bank).
That is £34,500 to £36,000 a year in running cost, plus a possible £6,000 to £9,000 to find them, before any commission or bonus. And before they have closed a sale.
A salaried rep also brings the rest of employment law: notice, holiday, sickness, and the cost of letting someone go if it does not work out.
What a commission-only rep costs you
Nothing until a sale closes. Then you pay the agreed commission, and the rate is higher than for employed reps because the rep carries their own costs and risk (see what commission rate should you offer).
The costs hide elsewhere:
- Your time. A rep needs briefing, materials and answers. A rep who gets none disappears (see why commission-only reps vanish).
- Commitment. They sell for other companies too. You are one of several.
- The legal line. If you control hours and methods the way you would for an employee, they may be a worker or employee in law, and then the minimum wage applies. See can you legally hire someone on commission only in the UK?.
What an agency costs
Models vary: a monthly retainer, a fee per meeting booked, a share of closed sales, or a mix. Get quotes and ask exactly what is charged before results and what only after. Some agencies and marketplaces charge nothing up front and take a cut of closed deals. An agency's strength is that someone else runs the process; its weakness is that you rely on a third party's attention and pay for their overhead.
Which should you choose?
- You have not yet shown the product sells: do some of the selling yourself first. Founders who advise against going commission-only early make the same point: you learn what the buyer cares about by taking the calls. Then test one or two commission-only reps. Read is commission-only sales worth it for a startup?.
- You have a proven, repeatable sale and cash: a salaried rep with commission gives you control and commitment.
- You want results without managing people: an agency, if the fee structure shares the risk.
- You are bootstrapped and want to pay only for sales: commission-only, with realistic expectations about commitment.
Many founders end up with a mix: a salaried core and commission-only reps on top for extra reach.
FAQ
Is commission-only cheaper than a salaried salesperson?
Until a sale closes, yes: it costs nothing. Per sale, commission can cost more than a salary spread across the same sales, because reps carry their own risk and expect a higher rate.
How much does it cost to employ a salesperson in the UK?
Employer National Insurance, pension and other costs commonly add about 15% to 20% to gross pay, and a recruiter may charge 20% to 30% of salary.
When should a startup use a sales agency?
When you want someone else to run outreach and are happy to pay for it, ideally under a fee structure that shares the risk.
Post a listing on WedgeUp for free and see how commission-only reps respond before you commit to a salary.