Is commission-only sales a scam?
Written by the founder of WedgeUp, a marketplace for commission-only sales work. I have an interest in this topic and say where it shows. This is general information, not legal advice.
No. Commission-only is a legitimate way to be paid, and plenty of people earn well on it. But some offers are scams, and the bad ones share patterns you can spot before you spend a penny or an hour. The test is simple: a real offer tells you who you are selling for, what you will earn on each sale, and when you will be paid, and it never asks you for money to start.
Why people are suspicious
The fear is earned. People who tried it and lost say so plainly:
- "just a huge scam", said of door-to-door commission-only recruiters in a 2011 AnandTech forum thread
- "I never even made enough money to cover my gas and I quit after 3 months", from a poster in the same thread who had tried a commission-only sales job
Both come from a 2011 thread, so they are old and about door-to-door work, but the fear they voice has not gone away. The other common fear is paying upfront and getting nothing: money out, no work back.
Those two stories are different problems. The first is an offer that was real but did not pay, often because the product was hard to sell or the lead supply was thin. The second is an offer that was built to take your money. Both are worth guarding against, and the checklists below do that.
How commission-only works
You sell for a company and are paid a share of each sale, with no base salary. The share can be a percentage of the first year, a percentage of every payment, or a flat fee per closed deal. If you sell nothing, you earn nothing, which is the whole point and the whole risk.
The legal point to get checked. In the UK, how you are classed matters. Minimum wage rights apply to workers, a legal category that includes employees. A person who is genuinely self-employed, running their own business and free to choose how and when to work, is not entitled to the minimum wage. But gov.uk guidance warns that someone assessed as self-employed for tax may still be a worker for minimum wage purposes, and that a "self-employed" label does not settle it (gov.uk: eligibility for the minimum wage). If a company controls your hours, tells you how to work and expects you to work only for it, you may be a worker whatever the contract says, and then commission alone does not meet the legal floor. See also Sprintlaw's guide to structuring commission-only roles. For the full picture, including the rules for commercial agents, see can you legally hire someone on commission only in the UK? I am not a lawyer and this is not legal advice: if the arrangement matters to you, take advice.
Red flags
- You pay to start. Training, a "starter kit", a licence, a lead pack. A real company pays you from sales, not before them.
- The recruiter will not name the company or the product. "A leading firm in a growing sector" is not an answer.
- No written commission terms. If the rate, the trigger and the payment date are not on paper, they can change.
- "Guaranteed" earnings. On commission-only, nobody can guarantee what you will earn. Promises like that are bait.
- Vague titles. "Business development associate", "brand ambassador" or "marketing partner" often hide a sales role with unclear terms.
- Pressure to buy training or leads. Once you are paying for the means to sell, the company profits whether or not you sell.
Green flags
- The commission rate and the payment date are written down. For example: 20% of the first year's revenue, paid within 30 days of the customer paying.
- A named, checkable product and buyer. You can look up the company and see that the product exists.
- A founder you can speak to before you start. A person who will take a call, not a form.
- No money from you before you sell.
Eight questions to ask before you start
- Who is the company, and can I look them up?
- What exactly does a customer buy, and what does it cost?
- What do I earn on each sale, and is it a percentage, a flat fee or both?
- When is commission paid: on signing, or when the customer pays?
- If a customer cancels or does not pay, is the commission taken back?
- Who owns the customer after the sale, and what happens to my commission if I leave?
- Do you give me leads, or do I find my own?
- Can I speak to someone who has sold this before, and how many deals did they close?
Save this list. If a founder gets awkward at questions 3 to 5, that is useful information.
Where WedgeUp fits
WedgeUp is a board of commission-only listings from founders. Each listing shows what a deal pays, and the company name stays hidden until you pay a small fee (£2 at launch, £4 list price) to unlock the founder's email.
That fee is a cost, so here is exactly what it buys and does not buy. It buys the founder's email address, for good. It does not buy a guarantee of work, a reply, or a deal. Founders are asked to reply within 3 to 5 days. If a founder has not replied 14 days after you unlock, you can email us and we will look at giving the unlock back; we do not refund an unlock once it has been used and the email revealed.
You should apply the same eight questions to a WedgeUp founder as to anyone else. The platform makes the introduction. It does not vouch for the deal.
FAQ
Is commission-only sales legal in the UK?
It can be, if the arrangement is genuinely self-employed. If you work like an employee, minimum wage rules may apply whatever the contract says. Take advice.
Can I make a living on commission-only?
Some people do, usually with a product that has a clear buyer and a high enough price per sale. Others treat it as a side income alongside a day job. Ask for realistic numbers and treat any promise of guaranteed earnings as a red flag.
Should I ever pay to start?
Be wary. Paying for training, leads or a starter kit before you have sold anything is the most common pattern in the bad offers.
Browse the WedgeUp board to see what real listings pay before you spend anything.