Why commission-only reps vanish, and how to keep them
Written by the founder of WedgeUp, a marketplace for commission-only sales work. I found no published data on how often these reps quit, so this post gives causes and fixes, not statistics.
Commission-only reps vanish when they cannot see how they will be paid. A rep with no salary spends their days on whichever product pays soonest. If yours has no leads, a long cycle, unclear terms or a founder who replies in a week, you lose to the next one. The fixes are cheap and mostly yours to make.
What founders say happened
Craig T Watkins, who works with early-stage B2B startups, describes the cycle: reps "leave as soon as something better appears. So we onboard, train, transfer context, and lose them. Then we do it again." He concludes that this "defers" the cost of a salary and "compounds it" (Commission-Only Sales Isn't Saving You Money, June 2026). It is one adviser's view, and his answer (do not hire commission-only until the pitch is proven) is not the only one, but the cycle he describes is the thing to avoid.
None of this is a character flaw in the reps. A person with no salary is making a rational choice every day about where to spend their hours.
Six causes, and the fix for each
These are common causes drawn from how commission-only work is structured. They are not measured.
- No leads. A rep who has to prospect cold, with no list and no warm introductions, may spend weeks earning nothing. Fix: give a starter list of 30 to 50 prospects, or introduce them to the first few yourself.
- The pitch is not written down. They guess the offer, get objections you could have answered, and lose confidence. Fix: one page covering the buyer, the problem, the price, three objections with answers.
- A long cycle with a late payout. If the sale takes three months and commission is paid 60 days after that, the rep has not earned anything for five months. Fix: shorten the payment delay, pay part on signing, or pay a small fee per qualified meeting.
- Silence from you. A rep with a question who waits a week for an answer moves on. Fix: reply within a day, and say how long you will take. On WedgeUp, founders are asked to reply within 3 to 5 days, which is the outer limit and not a goal.
- Unclear terms. If the rate, the trigger and the payment date are vague, trust goes quickly. Fix: write them down. See what commission rate should you offer.
- The earnings were oversold. A rep promised £5,000 and finding £300 leaves and tells others. Fix: put honest figures on the listing. See how to write a commission-only sales listing that gets replies.
A checklist for the first two weeks
- A one-page pitch and the answers to the three objections you hear most
- A demo account or sample they can show
- A starter list of prospects
- A 30-minute call on day one to walk through a real sale
- The commission terms on one page, agreed in writing
- A fixed slot each week when you answer questions, such as Tuesday morning
- A review at week four: what they tried, what happened, what to change
Choose the right rep
Some vanishing is the wrong fit. Reps who sell for a living and have an existing book of customers may pick you up as an extra, and treat it as one. Reps who are new to sales may need more support than you can give. Ask how many hours a week they can offer, what else they sell, and how they plan to start. A rep who gives a specific plan will probably act on it.
Keep it fair
If the rep works to a timetable you set, with your equipment, and only for you, you may be treating them as an employee, and the minimum wage may then apply. See can you legally hire someone on commission only in the UK?.
FAQ
Why do commission-only salespeople quit?
They quit when they cannot see a way to be paid soon: no leads, a long sales cycle, unclear commission, slow replies, or earnings that were oversold.
How do you keep a commission-only sales rep motivated?
Make the first sale easier, with leads, a written pitch and a fast response, and pay promptly. Honest expectations help more than a bonus.
How long should I give a commission-only rep before judging them?
Set a review point, such as 60 to 90 days, and agree it up front. Judge on activity and deals, not revenue alone.